NI044: keine Artefakt Erschaffungs SA

Im Champions Spiel NI044 wird es keine Artefakt Erschaffung Spezialaktion geben (können). D.h. ein Wahrer Runenmeister wird in NI044 die SA von Seite 138ff im Regelwerk nicht ausführen können.
Der Grund ist einfach der, dass diese SA den Spielern von Harlequin Games vollkommen unbekannt ist und ich lauter Probleme sehe, wenn man sie nun einführen würde. Deswegen müsst ihr leider drauf verzichten.

Hi Klaus,

I'm not sure I understand the reason of potential problems with the SA. There is no real difference between a HQ player doing this action for the first time and a SSV player doing it for the first time. Actually I would expect an experienced HQ player to do better than a new SSV player (ok, maybe exclude the Americans :laugh: )
There is even a good translation of the section in the rules (by Jens Schomburg) in the files section of LegHelp. It is from 2007, so needs a small update from the 2008 change, but other than that it looks good to me.

I could understand the reason of not allowing it because it might give a small advantage to SSV players. They can repeat good ideas from previous experience (or avoid bad ideas)

Ricco

Maybe you missunderstood the intention,

i think, reason for this decision is certainly not the opinion HG-players couldn`t cope with it,

quite the opposite.
Experience shows - if you forgive me the pun -
that players tend to stress the borders of new rules,

and this, in the past, already led to countless quarrels or at least "serious discussions" too often followed by "furious exit" of the offended player, who thinks himself unfairly treated,


a reaction which schould be avoided in this special game, since such would certainly tip the balance,

so why risk the trouble, when it could be easily avoided?

As one of those stuipd Americans (yea your on my in-game hit list now) I was looking forward to trying the artifact creation SA. That was my favorite part of the old Edi days.

- Brad

ok,that makes a lot of sense to me. Experienced players will try to stretch the boundaries and this may cause disagreement/discussion when the GM will not allow what they want.

I personally don't think it is a good enough reason not to allow it, but as I'm not the GM that has to cope with the fallout that is easy for me to say. I certainly have no problem with the decision.

Ricco

We could use artefact creation in NI044 or not, both ways are okay for me and this is not really importand. This could be discussed on the Whispers-Maillist.